Our Blog

Trusted Choice Pledge

Insurance Companies

Our Insurance Companies

Starr-Mathews is proud to partner with the companies below. To make a payment or to report a claim directly to the company, click on the appropriate link below. For assistance with claims contact Gaile Forsyth, Starr-Mathews Claims Specialist, at 800-627-4441 or 706-629-4441

A-C D-F G-I J-L M-O P-R S-U V-Z

A-C

Accident Fund of America

Payments: 866-206-5851

File a Claim: 866-206-5851

Affinity Service Group

Payments: 800-233-2436

File a Claim: 800-233-2436

AFM

Payments: 770-777-3600

File a Claim: 800-241-1022

Alliant

Payments: 800-221-5830

File a Claim:

Amerisafe

Payments: 800-265-9052

File a Claim: 800-699-6240

American Collectors Insurance

Payments: 800-360-2277

File a Claim: 800-360-2277

American Modern

Payments: 800-543-2644

File a Claim: 800-375-2075

AmTrust

Payments: 877-528-7878

File a Claim: 866-272-9267

Auto-Owners Insurance

Payments: 800-288-8740

File a Claim: 855-240-7255

Berkshire Hathaway

Payments: 877-680-2442

File a Claim: 800-488-2930

Builders Insurance Group

Payments: 800-475-4477

File a Claim: 800-822-2905

Central Insurance Companies

Payments: 800-786-9052

File a Claim: 770-740-8000

CHUBB

Payments: 908-572-3801

File a Claim: 800-252-4670

The Cincinnati Insurance Companies

Payments: 800-364-3400

File a Claim: 877-242-2544

Columbia Insurance Group

Payments: 800-767-4080

File a Claim: 800-877-3579

Ext. 1860

Payments: 855-875-5569

File a Claim:

D-F

Donegal Insurance Group

Payments: 800-877-0600

File a Claim: 800-277-7442

EMC Insurance

Payments: 800-239-2005

File a Claim: 888-362-2255

Employers

Payments: 888-682-6671

File a Claim: 888-682-6671

Encompass

Payments: 866-430-2916

File a Claim: 800-588-7400

FFVA Mutaul

Payments: 800-346-4825

File a Claim: 800-226-0666

Foremost Insurance Group

Payments: 800-527-3905

File a Claim: 800-527-3907

G-I

Berkshire Hathaway Gaurd Insurance Companies

Payments: 800-475-4477

File a Claim: 800-822-2905

Guardian

Payments: 1-888-482-7342

File a Claim:

Hagerty

Payments: 877-922-9701

File a Claim: 800-922-4050

The Hanover Insurance Group

Payments: 800-573-1187

File a Claim: 800-628-0250

Humana

Payments: 800-448-6262

File a Claim:

The Hartford

Payments:

800-624-5578 (Personal)

866-467-8730 (Commercial)

File a Claim: 800-553-1710

J-L

Johnson & Johnson

Payments: 800-487-7565

File a Claim: 800-487-7565

Liberty Mutual

Payments: 866-290-2920

File a Claim: 800-561-0178

M-O

P-R

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Payments: 877-438-7459

File a Claim: 877-765-9749

Principal

Payments: 800-986-3343

File a Claim:

Progressive

Payments: 800-876-5581

File a Claim: 800-776-4737

QBE

Payments: 800-553-4471

File a Claim: 888-737-8256

Payments: 800-986-3343

File a Claim:

S-U

Selective

Payments: 888-974-7400

File a Claim: 866-455-9969

Southern Trust

Payments: 800-476-5566

File a Claim: 844-812-2660

Standard

Payments: 800-628-9797

File a Claim:

Summit

Payments: 1-800-282-7648

File a Claim: 1-800-762-7811

Sun Life

Payments: 800-786-5433

File a Claim:

Travelers

Payments:

800-550-7716 (Personal)

800-252-2268 (Commercial)

File a Claim: 800-238-6225

United

Payments: 866-414-1959

File a Claim:

Unum

Payments: 866-679-3054

File a Claim:

US Assure

Payments: 855-872-7787

File a Claim: 855-872-7787

USLI

Payments: 866-632-2003

File a Claim: 888-875-5231

Utica National Insurance Group

Payments: 800-598-8422

File a Claim: 800-216-1420

V-Z

Westfield Insurance

Payments: 800-766-9133

File a Claim: 866-937-2663